Made-To-Order

Our signature product! These cinnamon rolls are a heritage Amish recipe, baked to perfection and coated generously in...

Amish Cinnamon Rolls Party Pack option of 24 small rolls for $60. These rolls are about 1/3 the size of our normal ci...

A boiled, brown sugar frosting made from a heritage recipe.  16oz

AVAILABLE FOR PICK-UP DECEMBER 24th ONLY! Between 7am-12pm Our luscious dinner rolls are made with mashed potatoes in...

Our Marshmallow Treats are a family favorite! Made with browned butter and a sprinkling of coarse sea salt, these com...

A delicious Devil’s Food chocolate cake, covered in Vanilla Buttercream and with velvety chocolate ganache between ea...

  Our Chocolate Peppermint Cake is a seasonal favorite made with our Devil's Food Chocolate Cake and covered in a flu...

Our Lemon Buttermilk Cake features subtle flavors of fresh lemon with layers of scratch-made lemon curd and covered i...

Our Devil's Food Chocolate Cake is ultra moist and fluffy, covered in a creamy Buttercream of your choice.

Gluten-free and nut-free, this fudgy & decadent single-layer cake is made with 70% dark Belgian chocolate and spr...

A taste of your grandmother's cozy kitchen, this lovely three-layer cake is baked with warm spices of ginger, cinnamo...

Our apple pie is baked with a variety of local apples and a cinnamon sugar mixture in our all-butter crust.

Baked in our flaky, all-butter crust and sweetened with maple syrup, this Pecan Pie is a southern all-time favorite!

A rich chocolate custard inside our flaky, grass-fed-butter crust!

  Rich, delightfully tart and just sweet enough, our Key Lime Pie is one of our biggest hits in-store. Made with a bu...

This elegant custard pie uses honey in place of sugar, with flecks of sea salt throughout and on top. Baked in our fl...